S03E17 · EP 17
season 3 · 2007-04-18

Catch-22

written by Jeff Pinkner & · Brian K. Vaughan · directed by Stephen Williams · 12.08M viewers

Episode DNA

24 scenes · 2 threads
tense 17%tender 9%lie 8%secret exposed 8%awkward 7%deadpan 6%confession 5%violence 5%chaotic 4%sad 4%

Story threads over runtime

click a block to open the scene
0:005:0010:0015:0020:00
A · Desmond's Past
B · Island Rescue Mission
01

Every scene

24 scenes · our breakdown
1 · Jungle · act1Desmond Warns Charlie

Desmond explains to Charlie that he foresaw his death and tried to save him.

00:00–01:21lie
2 · Jungle · act1Charlie Dies by Arrow

Charlie steps on a trap and is killed by an arrow.

01:21–03:19violence
3 · Beach · act1Desmond Asks About Cable

Desmond urgently asks Hurley about a buried cable.

03:19–04:46secret_exposed
4 · Monastery · act1Desmond Becomes a Monk

Brother Campbell welcomes Desmond after his vow of silence.

04:46–05:48
5 · Jack's house · act1Borrowing First Aid Kit

Desmond and Hurley borrow a first aid kit from Jack.

05:48–06:37lie
6 ▸ 06:37
6 · Outside Jack's · act1Desmond Explains His Vision

Desmond tells Hurley about his jigsaw puzzle vision.

06:37–08:23secret_exposed
7 · Beach · act1Kate and Sawyer Argue

Kate confronts Sawyer about their secret relationship.

08:23–09:52secret_exposed
8 · Beach · act1Recruiting Jin for Camping

Desmond and Hurley plan to get Jin to join them.

09:52–10:37scheme
9 · Beach · act1Convincing Jin to Join

Desmond convinces Jin to join the camping trip.

10:37–12:39lie
10 · Beach · act1Finding the Cable

The group finds the cable and camps for the night.

12:39–13:45
11 · Monastery · act1Discussing Sacrifice

Desmond and Brother Campbell discuss the meaning of sacrifice.

13:45–14:56violence
12 ▸ 14:56
12 · Beach camp · act2Desmond and Charlie Chat

Desmond and Charlie talk about being back at the beach and their nightly routines.

14:56–16:24coincidence
13 ▸ 16:24
13 · Charlie's tent · act2Sawyer Confronts Charlie

Sawyer finds Charlie crying and tells him to shut up.

16:24–18:18humiliation
14 · Beach camp · act2Desmond Shows Penny Photo

Desmond shows Charlie a photo of Penny and explains why he left her.

18:18–19:44confession
15 · Beach camp · act2Helicopter Crash Discovered

A helicopter crashes on the island and the group debates whether to search.

19:44–22:02pursuit
16 · Beach camp · act2Group Decides to Wait

The group agrees to wait until first light to search for the crash.

22:02–22:41negotiation
17 ▸ 22:41
17 · Ruth's house · act2Desmond Visits Ruth

Desmond visits his ex-fiancée Ruth to explain why he left her.

22:41–25:18confession · breakup
18 · Beach camp · act2Sawyer and Jack Play Ping Pong

Sawyer and Jack play ping pong and discuss the helicopter crash.

25:18–27:45interrogation
19 · Jungle · act2Satellite Phone Found

The group finds a satellite phone and a photo of Penny.

27:45–29:14coincidence
20 · Beach camp · act2Sawyer Gives Mix Tape to Kate

Sawyer gives Kate a mix tape and they discuss Desmond's visions.

29:14–31:00seduction
21 · Monastery · act2Desmond Fired from Monastery

Brother Campbell fires Desmond from the monastery for drinking wine.

31:00–33:52humiliation
22 · Jungle · act2Group Argues About Flash vs Superman

Charlie and Hurley argue about who would win in a footrace.

33:52–35:05petty_grievance
23 · Jungle · act2Charlie Confronts Desmond About Vision

Charlie realizes Desmond knew about the arrow trap and confronts him.

35:05–37:11confession · betrayal
24 ▸ 37:11
24 · Jungle · act2Penny Found Alive

The group finds Penny unconscious but alive in the jungle.

37:11–41:12coincidence
03

Same DNA

nearest episodes by gene profile

Episode facts

Wikipedia · Wikidata
Aired
2007-04-18
Overall
#17
Writers
Jeff Pinkner & · Brian K. Vaughan
Director
Stephen Williams
Viewers
12.08M (US)
Pace
78 words/min · 141 questions

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 6 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
Catch-22Digital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.