S01E12 · EP 12
season 1 · 2002-01-16

Silent Enemy

written by André Bormanis · directed by Winrich Kolbe · 6.11M viewers

Episode DNA

24 scenes · 3 threads
tense 16%tender 14%cheerful 14%awkward 11%misunderstanding 7%investigation 7%social rule violation 5%negotiation 5%sad 5%confession 4%

Story threads over runtime

click a block to open the scene
0:005:0010:0015:0020:00
A · Phlox's ethical dilemma
B · Alien epidemic crisis
C · Phlox and Cutler romance
01

Every scene

24 scenes · our breakdown
1 · Captain Archer's quarters · cold_openArcher feeds pet in quarters

Captain Archer tends to his pet creature in his quarters, humming and feeding it.

00:02–02:45lie · social_rule_violation
2 · Corridor on Enterprise · act1Hoshi and Phlox discuss letters

Hoshi teases Phlox about letters from a colleague, discussing pen pals.

02:45–03:36misunderstanding
3 · Sick bay on Enterprise · act1Phlox records letter to Lucas

Phlox records a personal letter to Dr. Lucas, discussing mating season and advice.

03:36–04:01
4 · Sick bay on Enterprise · act1Phlox treats Tucker's burn

Phlox treats Tucker's minor burn and discusses crew acceptance.

04:01–04:42
5 · Sick bay on Enterprise · act1Phlox treats Archer's pet

Phlox treats Captain Archer's pet for digestive issues caused by cheese.

04:42–05:37social_rule_violation
6 · Mess hall on Enterprise · act1Crew watches movie in mess hall

Phlox and crew watch a movie, observing emotional responses.

05:37–09:31
7 · Sick bay on Enterprise · act1Phlox and Cutler study anatomy

Phlox teaches Cutler anatomy, then they discuss human emotions and touch.

09:31–09:50social_rule_violation
8 · Sick bay and bridge · act1Phlox suspects Cutler's interest

Phlox records that Cutler may be romantically interested in him.

09:50–10:46misunderstanding
9 · Launch bay 2 on Enterprise · act1Aliens board Enterprise seeking help

Two alien astronauts from Valakis board Enterprise, seeking medical help for their dying people.

10:46–13:03negotiation
10 · Sick bay on Enterprise · act1Phlox records letter about epidemic

Phlox records a letter about the Valakian epidemic and his responsibility.

13:03–13:59
11 · Sick bay on Enterprise · act1Hoshi and Phlox discuss dating

Hoshi asks Phlox if he is dating Cutler, leading to a language lesson.

13:59–15:54misunderstanding
12 · Valakian clinic · act2Enterprise arrives at Valakis

Enterprise enters orbit around Valakis and Phlox begins treating patients.

15:54–17:14investigation
13 · Valakian clinic · act2Hoshi meets Menk worker

Hoshi encounters a Menk worker and learns about the two species' relationship.

17:14–17:53investigation
14 · Sick bay on Enterprise · act2Phlox records letter about Menk

Phlox records a letter about the Menk and his work with Cutler.

17:53–20:05
15 · T'Pol's quarters · act2Phlox asks T'Pol about interspecies mating

Phlox asks T'Pol about human interspecies relationships while she treats his tooth.

20:05–21:59misunderstanding
16 · Captain's ready room · act2Phlox reveals disease is genetic

Phlox tells Archer the Valakian illness is genetic and they will be extinct in 200 years.

21:59–23:36investigation
17 · Valakian planet surface · act2Phlox studies Menk on planet

Phlox and Hoshi study Menk, discovering their intelligence and Valakian exploitation.

23:36–26:51investigation
18 · Valakian planet surface · act2Phlox and Cutler discuss relationship

Phlox tells Cutler about his three wives, and she clarifies she wants friendship.

26:51–30:39confession
19 · Valakian leader's home · act2Valakian leader asks for warp drive

The Valakian leader thanks Archer but asks for warp technology to seek a cure.

30:39–32:49negotiation
20 · Bridge on Enterprise · act2Archer and T'Pol discuss warp refusal

Archer tells T'Pol the Valakians want warp technology, and they discuss the consequences.

32:49–35:14negotiation
21 · Mess hall on Enterprise · act3Phlox argues with Archer about cure

Phlox tells Archer he has a cure but withholding it may be ethical due to evolution.

35:14–38:29betrayal · secret_exposed
22 · Sick bay and Valakian clinic · act3Phlox records letter about decision

Phlox records that he trusted Archer to make the right choice about the cure.

38:29–41:48confession
23 · Corridor on Enterprise · tagPhlox gives letter to Hoshi

Phlox gives Hoshi a letter for Dr. Lucas and reflects on the taxing days.

41:48–42:35
24 · Sick bay on Enterprise · tagPhlox invites Cutler for snack

Phlox calls Cutler to invite her for a snack, saying he needs a friend.

42:35–43:16
03

Same DNA

nearest episodes by gene profile

Episode facts

Wikipedia · Wikidata
Aired
2002-01-16
Overall
#12
Writers
André Bormanis
Director
Winrich Kolbe
Viewers
6.11M (US)
Pace
110 words/min · 90 questions

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 4 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
Silent EnemyDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.

In this episode