S02E02 · EP 28
season 2 · 2002-09-25

Carbon Creek

written by Chris Black · directed by James A. Contner · 4.84M viewers

Episode DNA

23 scenes · 2 threads
tender 11%lie 9%tense 9%coincidence 7%triumphant 7%angry 7%escalation 4%awkward 4%cheerful 4%sad 4%

Story threads over runtime

click a block to open the scene
0:005:0010:0015:0020:00
A · T'Pol's Carbon Creek story
B · Vulcan survival in 1957
01

Every scene

23 scenes · our breakdown
1 · Enterprise mess hall · cold_openT'Pol's anniversary dinner

The crew celebrates T'Pol's one-year anniversary aboard Enterprise with wine and conversation.

00:05–04:17lie
2 · Enterprise mess hall · act1Vulcan ship crashes on Earth

T'Pol narrates how three Vulcans crash-landed on Earth in 1957 after Sputnik's launch.

04:17–07:20coincidence
3 · Pennsylvania woods · act1Vulcans debate eating a creature

The stranded Vulcans argue about killing a local animal for food to survive.

07:20–08:56escalation
4 · Pennsylvania woods · act1Vulcans disguise themselves

Mestral and Stron disguise as humans and head to town for food.

08:56–09:52impersonation
5 · Carbon Creek baseball field · act1Vulcans observe a baseball game

The Vulcans watch a baseball game and mistake it for combat.

09:52–10:51misunderstanding
6 · Carbon Creek diner · act1Vulcans enter a diner

The Vulcans enter a diner and try to get food without money.

10:51–12:48social_rule_violation
7 · Carbon Creek diner · act1Mestral hustles a pool game

Mestral challenges a local to pool to win money for food.

12:48–15:25bet · scheme
8 · Enterprise mess hall · act1Trip jokes about Vulcan pool hustle

Trip compares the story to a Twilight Zone episode, teasing T'Pol.

15:25–16:30
9 · Enterprise mess hall · act1Vulcans take odd jobs

The Vulcans work various jobs while waiting for rescue.

16:30–16:58
10 · Carbon Creek diner · act2Mestral bonds with Maggie and Jack

Mestral talks with Maggie and her son Jack about college and nuclear fears.

16:58–18:33petty_grievance
11 ▸ 18:33
11 · Carbon Creek house · act2Stron complains about menial work

Stron vents about fixing sinks and being called Moe, feeling degraded.

18:33–19:11humiliation
12 ▸ 19:11
12 · Carbon Creek house · act2Stron and Mestral argue about humanity

Stron and Mestral clash over humanity's worth and potential.

19:11–21:09escalation
13 ▸ 21:09
13 · Carbon Creek street · act2Mestral and Maggie kiss

Mestral and Maggie share a romantic moment after a baseball game.

21:09–24:01seduction
14 · Carbon Creek street · act2Stron confronts Mestral about Maggie

Stron accuses Mestral of lying and orders him to stop seeing Maggie.

24:01–25:56betrayal · lie
15 · Carbon Creek house · act2Jack talks to T'Mir about astronomy

Jack finds T'Mir meditating and they discuss astronomy and Sputnik.

25:56–27:36coincidence
16 ▸ 27:36
16 · Carbon Creek house · act2Mestral rescues trapped miners

Mestral uses a particle weapon to save miners despite Stron's objections.

27:36–30:05violence
17 ▸ 30:05
17 · Carbon Creek mine · act2Mestral guides rescue through mine

Mestral directs the rescue of trapped miners using his knowledge.

30:05–32:28pursuit
18 · Enterprise mess hall · act2Rescue ship arrives for Vulcans

A Vulcan ship finally responds to the distress signal and plans extraction.

32:28–33:10coincidence
19 · Carbon Creek street · act2Jack says goodbye to T'Mir

Jack tells T'Mir he can't afford college and says goodbye.

33:10–36:01petty_grievance
20 · Maggie's house · act2Mestral gives Maggie an invention

Mestral gives Maggie a technological invention that will change the world.

36:01–37:08secret_exposed
21 · Carbon Creek house · act3Mestral decides to stay on Earth

Mestral tells Stron he will remain on Earth to study humanity.

37:08–39:10betrayal
22 · Enterprise mess hall · act3T'Pol finishes her story

T'Pol reveals Mestral lived out his life on Earth and the story may be true.

39:10–40:52lie
23 · Enterprise mess hall · tagTrip and Archer question T'Pol

Trip and Archer realize T'Pol may have tricked them with her story.

40:52–41:23lie
03

Same DNA

nearest episodes by gene profile

Episode facts

Wikipedia · Wikidata
Aired
2002-09-25
Overall
#28
Writers
Chris Black
Director
James A. Contner
Viewers
4.84M (US)
Pace
73 words/min · 101 questions

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 4 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
Carbon CreekDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.

In this episode

Image credits (Wikimedia Commons): Chief Journalist Mark O. Piggott[1] · Public domain