S02E21 · EP 47
season 2 · 2003-04-23

The Breach

written by ? · directed by Robert Duncan McNeill · 3.19M viewers

Episode DNA

23 scenes · 3 threads
tense 17%pursuit 8%negotiation 7%angry 7%confession 7%sad 6%tender 6%investigation 4%interrogation 4%cheerful 4%

Story threads over runtime

click a block to open the scene
0:005:0010:0015:0020:00
A · Phlox's ethical dilemma
B · Cave rescue mission
C · Antaran-Denobulan reconciliation
01

Every scene

23 scenes · our breakdown
1 · Sickbay · cold_openPhlox shows a tribble

Phlox shows Cutler a tribble and receives an urgent message from the Denobulan Science Academy.

00:07–02:44lie · scheme
2 · Ready room · act1Archer briefs the rescue team

Archer explains the Denobulan scientists are trapped on Xantoras due to political instability.

02:44–04:07scheme · negotiation
3 · Corridor · act1Tucker and Reed prepare gear

Tucker and Reed pack equipment for the cave rescue while Archer negotiates with the Xantoras governor.

04:07–05:10negotiation
4 · Bridge · act1Antaran transport emergency

Enterprise rescues an Antaran transport with a reactor leak, bringing injured passengers aboard.

05:10–06:46investigation
5 · Cave entrance · act1Cave descent begins

Tucker, Reed, and Archer enter the cave system to find the Denobulan scientists.

06:46–07:55pursuit
6 · Cave cliff · act1Climbing down the cliff

The team rappels down a steep cliff inside the cave, with Tucker going first.

07:55–08:39pursuit
7 · Sickbay · act1Antaran refuses Phlox's treatment

The Antaran captain refuses Phlox's medical help due to historical hatred between their species.

08:39–11:12interrogation · secret_exposed
8 · Cave interior · act1Tucker finds Denobulan gear

Tucker discovers Denobulan equipment and rock samples, confirming they are on the right path.

11:12–13:17investigation
9 · Sickbay · act1Archer tries to change Antaran's mind

Archer pleads with the Antaran captain to accept Phlox's treatment and set aside prejudice.

13:17–16:49interrogation · confession
10 · Cave passage · act2Following geological clues

Tucker uses geological knowledge to choose the correct path through the cave.

16:49–19:00investigation
11 · Cave gap · act2Tucker injures his ankle

Tucker falls and injures his ankle during a rope swing, forcing him to stay behind.

19:00–21:34escalation
12 · Sickbay · act2Phlox confronts the Antaran

Phlox tries to treat the Antaran captain but is met with insults and accusations about Denobulan war crimes.

21:34–24:04interrogation · humiliation
13 · Mess hall · act2Phlox shares personal story

Phlox tells T'Pol about his grandmother's prejudice and how he tried to raise his children differently.

24:04–26:16confession
14 · Cave chamber · act2Archer and Reed find the scientists

Archer and Reed locate the three Denobulan scientists in the cave.

26:16–28:07pursuit
15 · Cave chamber · act2Scientists refuse to leave

The Denobulan scientists refuse to abandon their research despite the danger from Xantoras militants.

28:07–29:52negotiation · threat
16 · Sickbay · act2Phlox reveals his past fears

Phlox admits he had nightmares about Antarans as a child and shares his struggle with his son's prejudice.

29:52–32:53confession · secret_exposed
17 · Cave passage · act3Scientists delay with samples

The Denobulan scientists try to carry heavy rock samples, slowing the escape from the cave.

32:53–34:01pursuit · threat
18 · Cave exit · act3Cave bombing forces escape

Xantoras forces bomb the cave, forcing the team to climb out quickly without safety gear.

34:01–35:07violence · pursuit
19 · Bridge · act3Archer threatens Xantoras governor

Archer confronts the Xantoras governor about bombing the caves and threatens retaliation.

35:07–36:49negotiation · threat
20 · Sickbay · act3Antaran accepts treatment

The Antaran captain decides to accept Phlox's treatment after their conversation.

36:49–37:54confession · deal
21 · Shuttlepod · act3Escape from Xantoras

Tucker and the scientists escape the cave and are pursued by a Xantoras patrol ship.

37:54–39:22pursuit · violence
22 · Corridor · act3Antaran captain departs

The Antaran captain thanks Archer and agrees to travel with the Denobulan scientists.

39:22–41:18deal · negotiation
23 · Sickbay · tagPhlox records a message to his son

Phlox records a personal message to his estranged son Mettus, hoping to reconcile.

41:18–42:01confession
03

Same DNA

nearest episodes by gene profile

Episode facts

Wikipedia · Wikidata
Aired
2003-04-23
Overall
#47
Writers
Director
Robert Duncan McNeill
Viewers
3.19M (US)
Pace
88 words/min · 98 questions

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 4 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
The BreachDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.

In this episode