S02E09 · EP 35
season 2 · 1989-02-13

The Measure of a Man

written by Melinda M. Snodgrass · directed by Robert Scheerer

Episode DNA

22 scenes · 3 threads
tense 18%tender 13%triumphant 12%cheerful 7%negotiation 7%confession 7%awkward 5%investigation 5%angry 5%misunderstanding 3%

Story threads over runtime

click a block to open the scene
0:005:0010:0015:0020:00
A · Data's legal status hearing
B · Picard and Louvois reunion
C · Maddox's experiment attempt
01

Every scene

22 scenes · our breakdown
2 · Starbase 173 corridor · act1Picard meets Phillipa Louvois

Picard reunites with former prosecutor Louvois at Starbase 173.

00:51–03:55misunderstanding
3 · USS Enterprise bridge · act1Enterprise arrival at Starbase

The Enterprise arrives at Starbase 173 for port call.

03:55–05:19
4 · Starbase 173 corridor · act1Picard and Louvois catch up

Picard and Louvois discuss their past and her new JAG office.

05:19–06:38petty_grievance
5 · Starbase 173 corridor · act1Maddox introduced to Picard

Admiral introduces Commander Maddox who has a proposal for Picard.

06:38–08:05scheme
6 · USS Enterprise bridge · act1Maddox wants to disassemble Data

Maddox reveals he plans to disassemble Data for study.

08:05–11:08scheme · threat
7 · Picard's ready room · act1Picard and Data discuss options

Picard tells Data he cannot stop the transfer but Data refuses to submit.

11:08–12:54misunderstanding
8 · Louvois' office · act1Picard asks Louvois for help

Picard asks Louvois for legal help to stop Data's transfer.

12:54–16:08negotiation
9 · Data's quarters · act2Data resigns from Starfleet

Data resigns from Starfleet to avoid Maddox's experiment.

16:08–18:32avoidance
10 · Louvois' office · act2Louvois hearing on Data's status

Louvois holds a hearing where Maddox argues Data is property.

18:32–20:55investigation
11 · Enterprise crew lounge · act2Data says goodbye to friends

Data receives farewell gifts from his crewmates.

20:55–22:25
12 · Louvois' office · act2Louvois rules Data is property

Louvois rules Data is property of Starfleet based on old laws.

22:25–24:47investigation · negotiation
13 · Data's quarters · act2Picard tells Data they will fight

Picard tells Data he has challenged the ruling and they will fight.

24:47–25:47negotiation
14 · Riker's quarters · act2Riker studies Data's schematics

Riker accesses Data's technical schematics to prepare for the hearing.

25:47–26:34investigation
15 · Starbase 173 courtroom · act3Hearing begins Riker prosecutes

Riker argues Data is a machine in the hearing.

26:34–31:39interrogation · humiliation
16 · Louvois' office · act3Picard and Louvois discuss slavery

Picard argues that treating Data as property is slavery.

31:39–33:25
17 · Starbase 173 courtroom · act3Picard defends Data's sentience

Picard argues Data is sentient and calls him to the stand.

33:25–36:02confession
18 ▸ 36:02
18 · Starbase 173 courtroom · act3Picard cross-examines Maddox

Picard forces Maddox to admit Data meets criteria for sentience.

36:02–39:51interrogation · confession
19 ▸ 39:51
19 · Starbase 173 courtroom · act3Picard's closing argument

Picard argues the ruling will define liberty and slavery.

39:51–41:23
20 ▸ 41:23
20 · Starbase 173 courtroom · act3Louvois rules Data has freedom

Louvois rules Data is not property and has freedom to choose.

41:23–42:32confession
21 ▸ 42:32
21 · Starbase 173 courtroom · tagData refuses Maddox's procedure

Data formally refuses Maddox's experiment.

42:32–43:02negotiation
22 · Starbase 173 corridor · tagPicard and Louvois reconcile

Picard and Louvois reconcile and agree to have dinner.

43:02–43:47
23 · Enterprise corridor · tagRiker and Data share a moment

Riker apologizes to Data for almost costing him his life.

43:47–44:47confession
03

Same DNA

nearest episodes by gene profile

Episode facts

Wikipedia · Wikidata
Aired
1989-02-13
Overall
#35
Writers
Melinda M. Snodgrass
Director
Robert Scheerer
Pace
99 words/min · 105 questions

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 7 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
The Measure of a ManDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.

In this episode