S04E09 · EP 48
season 4 · 2002-11-10

Whoever Did This

written by Mitchell Burgess, Robin Green · directed by Tim Van Patten · 9.83M viewers

Episode DNA

24 scenes · 4 threads
scheme 13%tense 12%sad 9%deadpan 9%angry 8%absurd 7%tender 5%violence 4%chaotic 4%awkward 3%

Story threads over runtime

click a block to open the scene
0:005:0010:0015:0020:00
A · Ralph's son accident
B · Junior fakes dementia
C · Paulie prank revenge
D · Ralph horse fire murder
01

Every scene

24 scenes · our breakdown
1 ▸ 01:15
1 · Federal Courthouse · cold_openCourt evidence concludes

Judge ends day's testimony and warns jury not to discuss case.

01:15–01:57scheme · negotiation
2 ▸ 01:57
2 · Federal Courthouse Steps · cold_openJunior falls down steps

Junior collapses on courthouse steps, causing media frenzy.

01:57–02:34coincidence · humiliation
3 · Stable · cold_openCarmela visits horse stable

Carmela meets Lois at the stable to see Pie-O-My.

02:34–03:41obsession · deal
4 · Hospital Room · act1Junior neurological check

Junior undergoes neurological checks in hospital.

03:41–04:58scheme · avoidance
5 · Hospital Corridor · act1Tony suspects Paulie

Tony theorizes Paulie spread the Ginny Sack joke.

04:58–05:36petty_grievance · betrayal
6 · Green Grove Retirement Home · act1Paulie pranks his mother

Paulie calls his mother pretending to be a detective.

05:36–07:11impersonation · humiliation
7 ▸ 07:11
7 · Hospital Room · act1Junior fakes dementia

Junior and Tony plan to fake dementia for trial.

07:11–08:19scheme
8 · Ralph's House · act1Ralph's son shot with arrow

Ralph's son Justin is accidentally shot with an arrow.

08:19–09:39violence
9 ▸ 09:39
9 · Hospital Emergency Room · act1Hospital confrontation

Justin's parents argue at the hospital over blame.

09:39–11:30violence
10 · Hospital Room · act2Lawyer plans dementia defense

Lawyer explains dementia defense strategy to Junior.

11:30–12:27scheme
11 · Carmela's House · act2Rosalie visits Carmela

Rosalie and Carmela discuss Justin's condition.

12:27–13:34
12 · Hospital Room · act2Junior practices dementia

Junior practices faking dementia with Tony.

13:34–15:07scheme · humiliation
13 · Hospital Room · act2Svetlana brings nurse

Svetlana introduces a nurse for Junior.

15:07–15:56negotiation
14 ▸ 15:56
14 · Hospital Chapel · act2Ralph prays with priest

Ralph questions God about his son's suffering.

15:56–18:25confession
15 · Soprano Kitchen · act2Carmela hears Ralph news

Carmela tells Tony about Ralph's scholarship and proposal.

18:25–19:41deal
16 · Soprano Living Room · act2Ralph visits Tony

Ralph visits Tony to discuss his son's condition.

19:41–21:47confession
17 · Soprano Living Room · act2Ralph reveals new girlfriend

Ralph tells Tony he is dating his ex-girlfriend Valentina.

21:47–23:45betrayal · rivalry
18 · Soprano Driveway · act2Ralph talks about horse

Ralph discusses the horse race with Tony.

23:45–24:49obsession
19 ▸ 24:49
19 · Soprano Basement · act3Paulie threatens Ralph

Paulie vows revenge on Ralph for the prank on his mother.

24:49–26:45threat · betrayal
20 · Hospital Room · act3Junior dementia test continues

Junior struggles with memory test questions.

26:45–27:51scheme
21 · Soprano House · act3Stable fire reported

Lois calls Tony about a fire at the stables.

27:51–29:10
22 ▸ 29:10
22 · Ralph's House · act3Tony confronts Ralph about fire

Tony accuses Ralph of setting the stable fire.

29:10–35:30violence · betrayal
23 · Ralph's House · act3Tony and Christopher dispose body

Tony and Christopher clean up Ralph's body.

35:30–40:22scheme
24 · Farm · tagBody buried and aftermath

Tony and Christopher bury Ralph's body.

40:22–54:27scheme
03

Same DNA

nearest episodes by gene profile

Episode facts

Wikipedia · Wikidata
Aired
2002-11-10
Overall
#48
Writers
Mitchell Burgess, Robin Green
Director
Tim Van Patten
Viewers
9.83M (US)
Pace
77 words/min · 121 questions

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 6 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
Whoever Did ThisDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.