S03E05 · SCENE 16/18 · 20:14
The Cost of Living · Hydra Island

Ben Reveals His Plan to Break Jack

Ben reveals his plan to manipulate Jack and asks if he believes in God.

20:14→22:59
in the episode · 2m 45s · S03E05

What happens

20:14–22:59

Ben asks to speak to Jack alone, citing doctor-patient confidentiality. Ben reveals his plan to break Jack by wearing him down and exploiting Juliet's resemblance to Jack's ex-wife. Ben admits the plan failed when Jack saw the X-rays. Ben asks Jack if he believes in God and says a spinal surgeon falling from the sky is proof of God.

WhereHydra Island
DriverBen
Positionact1 · reveal
ThreadJack's Captivity

Key lines

from this scene
20:51

We had such a wonderful plan to break you, Jack.

21:19

Has it not occurred to you Juliet bears a striking resemblance to your ex-wife?

More quotes on the Lost Wiki →

Scene DNA

weights 0–1
scheme1.0
confession1.0
tense1.0
monologue

Beats

20:51Ben reveals his plan to break Jack.
22:37Ben says the surgeon is proof of God.

Scene in the episode

20:14–22:59
B · Jack's Captivity

Collect it

eBay
More on eBay →
Links earn SceneClip a commission.

Merch on Amazon

sponsored
AMZN
The Cost of Living merchShirts, mugs, posters
Shop
AMZN
Jack Shephard merchFigures, shirts, gifts
Shop
AMZN
Juliet Burke merchFigures, shirts, gifts
Shop
AMZN
Lost giftsGift ideas for fans
Shop
Links may earn SceneClip a commission.

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 6 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
The Cost of LivingDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.