S05E02 · SCENE 1/21 · 00:02
The Lie · Penny's boat the Searcher
Oceanic Six debate lying
The Oceanic Six argue about whether to lie about the island.
00:02→02:17
in the episode · 2m 15s · S05E02
What happens
00:02–02:17Jack insists they must lie to protect those left behind from Charles Widmore. Hurley disagrees, wanting to tell the truth, but Sayid reluctantly sides with Jack. Hurley warns Sayid he will remember this.
Key lines
from this scene01:08We all saw it, it's gone.
01:20Not if someone backs me up.
Scene DNA
weights 0–1argument
Beats
00:43Jack argues lying protects survivors
01:53Hurley warns Sayid he won't help him
Scene in the episode
00:02–02:17Clips from this episode
fan uploads · YouTube · matched by frameIncludes this scene · Lost 5x02 The Lie-Boat Scene · LostHorror815
Includes this scene · LOST HD | Jack and Kate [S05E02] "The Lie" | Losttheothers · Losttheothers
Who's in it
Jack ShephardMatthew Fox105 episodes · drives 385 scenes
Kate AustenEvangeline Lilly105 episodes · drives 148 scenes
Frank LapidusJeff Fahey28 episodes · drives 10 scenes
Sayid JarrahNaveen Andrews105 episodes · drives 157 scenes

Desmond Hume67 episodes · drives 113 scenes
Merch on Amazon
sponsoredLinks may earn SceneClip a commission.



