S01E04 · EP 4
season 1 · 2017-10-08

The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry

written by Jesse Alexander, Aron Eli Coleite · directed by Olatunde Osunsanmi

Episode DNA

22 scenes · 4 threads
tense 17%tender 14%escalation 8%scheme 7%investigation 7%triumphant 6%confession 6%secret exposed 4%awkward 4%violence 3%

Story threads over runtime

click a block to open the scene
0:005:0010:0015:0020:00
A · Spore Drive Navigation
B · Ripper Creature Study
C · Corvan 2 Rescue
D · Michael's New Start
01

Every scene

22 scenes · our breakdown
1 · USS Discovery · cold_openPreviously on Discovery

Recap of past events sets up Michael's arrival and the spore drive.

00:07–02:03lie · scheme
2 · USS Discovery quarters · act1Michael Reports to Discovery

Michael arrives on Discovery and receives a message from Captain Georgiou.

02:03–03:52lie
3 · USS Discovery bridge · act1Saru Confronts Michael

Saru confronts Michael about her presence on the ship.

03:52–05:13social_rule_violation · interrogation
4 · USS Discovery bridge · act1Spore Drive Simulation

The crew runs a spore drive simulation that ends in disaster.

05:13–06:53escalation · scheme
5 · USS Discovery containment pen · act1Lorca Shows Michael Ripper

Lorca shows Michael the creature Ripper and tasks her with weaponizing it.

06:53–12:47scheme · threat
6 · USS Discovery lab · act1Michael and Landry Debate Ripper

Michael argues with Landry about Ripper's nature and purpose.

12:47–15:07misunderstanding · petty_grievance
7 · USS Discovery bridge · act1Corvan 2 Distress Call

The crew receives a distress call from Corvan 2 and plans a rescue.

15:07–19:46scheme · escalation
8 · USS Discovery bridge · act2First Spore Jump Fails

The first spore jump fails, landing the ship near a star.

19:46–21:32escalation · coincidence
9 · USS Discovery lab · act2Michael Links Ripper to Drive

Michael discovers Ripper reacts to the spore drive.

21:32–21:45investigation · secret_exposed
10 · USS Discovery engineering · act2Lorca and Stamets Clash

Lorca and Stamets argue about the spore drive's readiness.

21:45–23:59scheme · humiliation
11 · USS Discovery bridge · act2Corvan 2 Pleas Heard

The crew hears desperate pleas from Corvan 2 colonists.

23:59–24:55escalation · threat
12 · USS Discovery containment pen · act2Landry Attacks Ripper

Landry attempts to sedate and attack Ripper, leading to her death.

24:55–27:26violence · escalation
13 · USS Discovery quarters · act2Michael Searches for Answers

Michael accesses the crew manifest to investigate Ripper.

27:26–29:55investigation · obsession
14 · USS Discovery corridor · act2Michael and Saru Reconcile

Michael apologizes to Saru, and they discuss Ripper's nature.

29:55–31:14confession · misunderstanding
15 · USS Discovery quarters · act2Tilly Helps Michael

Tilly brings Michael spores from the Glenn for her investigation.

31:14–31:56scheme · investigation
16 · USS Discovery containment pen · act2Michael Befriends Ripper

Michael approaches Ripper with spores and gains its trust.

31:56–33:27deal · coincidence
17 · USS Discovery lab · act2Ripper is the Navigator

Michael and Stamets discover Ripper can navigate the spore drive.

33:27–37:54investigation · secret_exposed
18 · USS Discovery bridge · act3Successful Jump to Corvan 2

The crew uses Ripper to navigate a successful jump to Corvan 2.

37:54–41:20escalation · violence
19 · Vulcan Science Academy · act3Michael's Past Revealed

Michael's past as a Vulcan Science Academy graduate is revealed.

41:20–43:35secret_exposed · double_standard
20 · USS Discovery containment pen · act3Michael Visits Ripper

Michael visits Ripper after the successful mission.

43:35–44:23deal · confession
21 · USS Discovery quarters · act3Tilly Encourages Michael

Tilly encourages Michael to open Georgiou's message.

44:23–46:12confession · petty_grievance
22 · USS Discovery quarters · tagMichael Opens Georgiou's Message

Michael opens Georgiou's final message and is moved by it.

46:12–47:40confession · secret_exposed
03

Same DNA

nearest episodes by gene profile

Episode facts

Wikipedia · Wikidata
Aired
2017-10-08
Overall
#4
Writers
Jesse Alexander, Aron Eli Coleite
Director
Olatunde Osunsanmi
Pace
71 words/min · 50 questions

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 5 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's CryDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.

In this episode