S03E12 · SCENE 18/24 · 28:37
There Is a Tide… · Federation Headquarters

Vance and Osyraa Argue Over Ethics

Vance and Osyraa clash over Federation ethics and slavery.

28:37→29:38
in the episode · 1m 01s · S03E12

What happens

28:37–29:38

Vance and Osyraa argue about replicator technology and slavery. Osyraa demands the Federation sanction trade with the Chain and allow an embassy. Vance accuses the Chain of trafficking slaves.

WhereFederation Headquarters
DriverOsyraa
Positionact2 · escalation
ThreadOsyraa's Hijack Negotiation

Key lines

from this scene
28:58

It doesn't quite taste like the real thing, does it?

29:18

We deconstruct it to the atomic level and then reform the atoms.

More quotes on the Memory Alpha →

Scene DNA

weights 0–1
negotiation1.0
double standard1.0
angry1.0
tense1.0
argument

Beats

29:08Vance criticizes replicator food

Scene in the episode

28:37–29:38
A · Osyraa's Hijack Negotiation
B · Michael and Book Retake Discovery
C · Stamets and Aurellio Debate
D · Crew Mutiny and Sphere Data

Who's in it

—

Props in this scene

shop
Links may earn SceneClip a commission.

Collect it

eBay
More on eBay →
Links earn SceneClip a commission.

Merch on Amazon

sponsored
AMZN
There Is a Tide… merchShirts, mugs, posters
Shop
AMZN
Star Trek: Discovery giftsGift ideas for fans
Shop
Links may earn SceneClip a commission.

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 5 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
There Is a Tide…Digital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.