S01E01 · SCENE 21/42 · 33:07
Star Trek · Starfleet Academy Hearing Room

Kirk accused of cheating

Spock accuses Kirk of cheating on the Kobayashi Maru test and they argue about the nature of the test.

33:07→35:09
in the film · 2m 02s

What happens

33:07–35:09

Spock calls a hearing and accuses Kirk of cheating by hacking the simulation. Kirk argues the test itself is a cheat because it is unwinnable. Spock says the purpose is to experience fear. Kirk says he doesn't believe in no-win scenarios.

WhereStarfleet Academy Hearing Room
DriverSpock
Positionact1 · reveal
ThreadKirk's origin and rise

Key lines

from this scene
33:33

Yes, I believe I have the right to face my accuser directly.

34:02

-Your point being? -In academic vernacular, you cheated.

More quotes on the Memory Alpha →

Scene DNA

weights 0–1
tense0.8
interrogation0.6
scheme0.4
deadpan0.2
argument

Beats

33:56Spock says Kirk cheated.
34:29Spock says a captain cannot cheat death.

Scene in the film

33:07–35:09
B · Spock's heritage and conflict
C · Nero's revenge plot

Clips from this film

fan uploads · YouTube · matched by frame
Includes this scene · Kirk Beats Spock's Test | Star Trek (2009) · NOW SCI-FI
Star Trek 2009 | Vulkans science academy scene · ElectricSteam
EPIC Space Battles | USS Kelvin vs Narada | Star Trek 2009 · Wolftime Gaming
Star Trek 1 leaving Earth for Entrprs to "punch it" · Michael and Stephanie Sandberg
Chris Hemsworth's Kamikaze Mission | Star Trek | CLIP · Boxoffice Movie Scenes
2009 Star Trek Bar Fight · Alexa Rapach
Star Trek (8/9) Movie CLIP - Spock Meets Spock (2009) HD · Movieclips
Star Trek 2009 - Kirk gets kicked off Enterprise · Yadah Gordon
Star Trek Final Battle · DB Film Scenes
Final Battle Scene | Star Trek (2009) · NOW SCI-FI
Star Trek 2009 - Kirk bed scene · Yadah Gordon
Starfleet’s Most Dangerous First Contact Battle | Star Trek (2009) | CLIP 💥 4K · JoBlo Sci-Fi 4K

Who's in it

—

Props in this scene

shop
Links may earn SceneClip a commission.

Collect it

eBay
More on eBay →
Links earn SceneClip a commission.

Merch on Amazon

sponsored
AMZN
Star Trek merchShirts, mugs, posters
Shop
AMZN
Star Trek giftsGift ideas for fans
Shop
Links may earn SceneClip a commission.

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream itWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
Blu-ray / DVDDisc
Shop
EP
Star TrekDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.