The women pressure Holly to give A.J. an ultimatum, and Dwight throws a tantrum.

The office argues after Jim breaks a window with a lacrosse stick, and Michael tells a story.

Michael tells a tall tale about Tara, which Jim and Dwight doubt, and Michael accuses Toby of vandalism.

Michael accuses Toby of ruining the Woody doll, and the office argues.

Michael admits he poured coffee on the Woody doll out of jealousy, horrifying Holly.

Michael lashes out at Holly and the party, then asks Erin for his clothes.

Jim opens a prank gift from Dwight, and the room laughs.

Toby complains he's never gotten jury duty, and Darryl's daughter asks to read.

Andy and Pam's Grinch-themed scavenger hunt for Jada ends abruptly when the star is found.

A.J. shows up unannounced at the party and surprises Holly.

Jada struggles to pick a snack from the vending machines while gifts are exchanged.

Pam opens Jim's diamond bracelet gift and then reads her homemade comic for him.

Pam follows Michael outside and tells him about Holly's ultimatum to A.J., urging patience.

Jim surrenders, but Dwight demands he hit Pam in the face with a snowball.

Holly tells A.J. that Woody fell into salad dressing, and Michael gives Erin a pie.

Erin lists presents she wants from Santa, including a horse, and Darryl's daughter is reluctant to leave.

Dwight chains the doors shut and pummels Jim with snowballs, drawing blood.