S04E12 · SCENE 16/33 · 24:57
Eloise · Meadow's apartment

Family argues about Billy Budd being gay

The dinner table erupts in a heated debate about whether Billy Budd is a homosexual book.

24:57→28:21
in the episode · 3m 24s · S04E12

What happens

24:57–28:21

At dinner, the family argues about Billy Budd being a gay book. Carmela insists it is not, but Meadow and Finn cite literary critics. Tony jokes about it, and Carmela gets defensive.

WhereMeadow's apartment
DriverCarmela Soprano
Positionact2 · escalation
ThreadMeadow's independence and Finn

Key lines

from this scene
24:58

Yo, guys, come here, look at this.

25:54

My daughter's an Italian princess. Does that count?

More quotes on the The Sopranos Wiki →

Scene DNA

weights 0–1
awkward0.7
misunderstanding0.6
social rule violation0.4
absurd0.3
argument

Beats

24:58Debate about Billy Budd begins
27:58Carmela dismisses literary critics

Scene in the episode

24:57–28:21
A · Tony vs Carmine HUD dispute
B · Furio's departure and Carmela
C · Meadow's independence and Finn
D · Paulie's loyalty and Junior trial

Clips from this episode

fan uploads · YouTube · matched by frame
Includes this scene · The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: Carmela hates gay nonsense in popular culture · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: Meadow and Carmela have lunch and talk about love · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: Finn's first appearance · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: AJ and Meadow talk about their mother · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: Carmela going through menopause · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999- 2007) Eloise: Meadow hates Carmela · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999- 2007) Eloise: Carmela's "date" with Furio · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: Paulie and Sil are "friends" · Alfred C. Chu

Props in this scene

shop
Links may earn SceneClip a commission.

Collect it

eBay
More on eBay →
Links earn SceneClip a commission.

Merch on Amazon

sponsored
AMZN
Eloise merchShirts, mugs, posters
Shop
AMZN
Tony Soprano merchFigures, shirts, gifts
Shop
AMZN
Carmela Soprano merchFigures, shirts, gifts
Shop
AMZN
The Sopranos giftsGift ideas for fans
Shop
Links may earn SceneClip a commission.

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 6 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
EloiseDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.