S04E12 · SCENE 16/33 · 24:57
Eloise · Meadow's apartment
Family argues about Billy Budd being gay
The dinner table erupts in a heated debate about whether Billy Budd is a homosexual book.
24:57→28:21
in the episode · 3m 24s · S04E12
What happens
24:57–28:21At dinner, the family argues about Billy Budd being a gay book. Carmela insists it is not, but Meadow and Finn cite literary critics. Tony jokes about it, and Carmela gets defensive.
Key lines
from this scene24:58Yo, guys, come here, look at this.
25:54My daughter's an Italian princess. Does that count?
Scene DNA
weights 0–1argument
Beats
24:58Debate about Billy Budd begins
27:58Carmela dismisses literary critics
Scene in the episode
24:57–28:21Clips from this episode
fan uploads · YouTube · matched by frameIncludes this scene · The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: Carmela hates gay nonsense in popular culture · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: Meadow and Carmela have lunch and talk about love · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: Finn's first appearance · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: AJ and Meadow talk about their mother · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: Carmela going through menopause · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999- 2007) Eloise: Meadow hates Carmela · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999- 2007) Eloise: Carmela's "date" with Furio · Alfred C. Chu
The Sopranos (1999–2007) Eloise: Paulie and Sil are "friends" · Alfred C. Chu
Who's in it
Tony SopranoJames Gandolfini85 episodes · drives 981 scenes
Carmela SopranoEdie Falco85 episodes · drives 234 scenes
Meadow SopranoJamie-Lynn Sigler85 episodes · drives 51 scenes
Merch on Amazon
sponsoredLinks may earn SceneClip a commission.


