S05E11 · EP 11
season 5 · April 1, 2009

Whatever Happened, Happened

written by Carlton Cuse & · Damon Lindelof · directed by Bobby Roth

Episode DNA

24 scenes · 3 threads
tense 19%tender 14%confession 12%sad 7%angry 6%secret exposed 4%misunderstanding 4%betrayal 4%scheme 3%violence 3%

Story threads over runtime

click a block to open the scene
0:005:0010:0015:0020:00
A · Kate's Off-Island Journey
B · Saving Young Ben
C · Time Travel Paradoxes
01

Every scene

24 scenes · our breakdown
1 · Various locations · cold_openPreviously on Lost Recap

Recap of past events sets up the episode's conflicts.

00:01–00:32lie · scheme
2 · Jungle near Barracks · act1Jin Finds Ben Shot

Jin discovers a wounded Ben and calls for help.

00:32–01:56violence
3 · Barracks courtyard · act1Horace Briefs DHARMA

Horace addresses DHARMA personnel about the prisoner escape.

01:56–02:58investigation
4 · Motor pool near burned van · act1Roger Meets Kate

Roger Linus asks Kate for help with a winch.

02:58–04:56coincidence
5 · Cassidy's house · act1Kate Visits Cassidy

Kate brings Aaron to Cassidy and explains Sawyer's request.

04:56–09:05confession · secret_exposed
6 · Security monitor room · act1Sawyer Confronts Kate

Sawyer orders Kate to stay quiet about Ben's shooting.

09:05–10:34investigation · secret_exposed
7 · Infirmary · act1Juliet Tries to Save Ben

Juliet struggles to stop Ben's bleeding.

10:34–11:39violence
8 ▸ 11:39
8 · House in Barracks · act1Hurley and Miles Debate Time

Hurley and Miles argue about time travel consequences.

11:39–13:06misunderstanding
9 ▸ 13:06
9 · House in Barracks · act1Jack Refuses to Help

Jack refuses to save young Ben, citing past events.

13:06–15:34betrayal
10 · Infirmary · act1Kate Donates Blood

Kate gives blood to help save young Ben.

15:34–16:55confession
11 · Infirmary · act1Roger Blames Himself

Roger admits he may have caused Ben's actions.

16:55–18:28confession
12 · Infirmary and house · act1Hurley Questions Time Logic

Hurley challenges Miles' theory about time travel.

18:28–20:46misunderstanding
13 · Infirmary · act1Juliet Suggests the Others

Juliet realizes the Others might save Ben.

20:46–22:20scheme
14 · Barracks to jungle · act1Kate Takes Ben to Others

Kate and Juliet take Ben to the Others for help.

22:20–23:14pursuit
15 · Los Angeles street · act2Jack Confronts Kate

Jack tries to convince Kate to return to the Island.

23:14–23:51betrayal · misunderstanding
16 · Grocery store · act2Kate Loses Aaron in Store

Kate briefly loses Aaron in a grocery store.

23:51–26:06coincidence
17 · Jungle path · act2Sawyer Helps Kate

Sawyer agrees to help Kate save Ben.

26:06–27:14deal
18 · Cassidy's house · act2Cassidy Counsels Kate

Cassidy tells Kate she kept Aaron to heal her heart.

27:14–29:10confession
19 · Jungle near Others' territory · act2Sawyer Explains His Motive

Sawyer tells Kate why he is helping her save Ben.

29:10–30:15confession
20 · House in Barracks · act2Juliet Confronts Jack

Juliet tells Jack he came back for himself.

30:15–32:06confession · betrayal
21 · Jungle clearing · act2Sawyer and Kate Talk

Sawyer and Kate discuss their past and Clementine.

32:06–33:39confession
22 · Others' territory line · act2Others Confront Sawyer

Sawyer and Kate are captured by the Others.

33:39–34:19threat · negotiation
23 · Carole Littleton's house · act2Kate Tells Carole Truth

Kate reveals the truth about Aaron and Claire to Carole.

34:19–38:27confession · secret_exposed
24 · Others' camp · act3Richard Takes Ben

Richard Alpert agrees to take young Ben.

38:27–41:55deal
03

Same DNA

nearest episodes by gene profile

Episode facts

Wikipedia · Wikidata
Aired
April 1, 2009
Overall
#11
Writers
Carlton Cuse & · Damon Lindelof
Director
Bobby Roth
Pace
87 words/min · 156 questions

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 6 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
Whatever Happened, HappenedDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.

In this episode

Cassidy Phillips3 episodes · drives 3 scenes
Dan Norton5 episodes · drives 3 scenes
Phil7 episodes
Horace Goodspeed6 episodes · drives 5 scenes