S05E12 · EP 12
season 5 · April 8, 2009

Dead is Dead

written by Brian K. Vaughan · & Elizabeth Sarnoff · directed by Stephen Williams

Episode DNA

21 scenes · 4 threads
tense 25%menacing 12%secret exposed 10%threat 9%confession 8%violence 7%sad 6%angry 6%rivalry 2%pursuit 2%

Story threads over runtime

click a block to open the scene
0:005:0010:0015:0020:00
A · Ben's flashback timeline
B · Ben and Locke on Island
C · Sun and Lapidus at Barracks
D · Ben's 2007 revenge
01

Every scene

21 scenes · our breakdown
1 · Various · cold_openPreviously on Lost

Recap of Sayid shooting young Ben and Alex's death.

00:00–01:01violence · threat
2 · Others' camp tent · act1Widmore visits young Ben

Charles Widmore talks to injured young Ben in a tent.

01:01–02:58negotiation · secret_exposed
3 · Beach near Hydra station · act1Ben meets resurrected Locke

Ben wakes to find Locke alive and discusses judgment.

02:58–04:52confession · secret_exposed
4 · Beach near Hydra station · act1Ben talks to Caesar

Ben speaks with Caesar about Locke's claims.

04:52–06:53scheme · lie
5 · Beach tent · act1Ben takes baby Alex

Ben enters Rousseau's tent and takes her baby.

06:53–09:07violence · threat
6 · Hydra station office · act2Locke confronts Ben in office

Locke questions Ben about killing him and his motives.

09:07–11:57confession · secret_exposed
7 ▸ 11:57
7 · Dock near Hydra station · act2Ben takes boat with Locke

Ben and Locke take a boat despite Caesar's objections.

11:57–14:00threat · violence
8 · Barracks dock · act2Ben and Locke arrive at Barracks

Ben and Locke discuss Ben's daughter's death on the island.

14:00–15:50confession · secret_exposed
9 · Others' camp · act2Ben refuses to kill baby Alex

Widmore orders Ben to kill baby Alex but Ben refuses.

15:50–17:39negotiation · threat
10 · Barracks street · act2Locke questions Ben's leadership

Locke questions Ben about moving into the Barracks.

17:39–19:09interrogation · rivalry
11 · Barracks house · act2Sun meets Locke at Barracks

Sun and Lapidus encounter Locke alive at the Barracks.

19:09–23:43coincidence · secret_exposed
12 ▸ 23:43
12 · Barracks dock · act2Ben exiles Widmore

Ben watches Widmore being exiled from the island.

23:43–25:52rivalry · comeuppance
13 · Barracks house · act3Sun questions Locke's resurrection

Sun asks Ben about Locke's return from the dead.

25:52–27:13secret_exposed · confession
14 · Jungle near Barracks · act3Ben and Locke head to Temple

Ben and Locke go to summon the monster at the Temple.

27:13–28:43pursuit · threat
15 · Marina · act3Ben calls Widmore about Penny

Ben calls Charles Widmore to threaten killing Penny.

28:43–29:35threat · violence
16 · Temple wall · act3Ben and Locke enter Temple

Ben and Locke go under the Temple wall.

29:35–31:50pursuit · secret_exposed
18 ▸ 32:41
18 · Marina boat · act3Ben confronts Penny on boat

Ben holds Penny at gunpoint but hesitates.

32:41–34:07violence · threat
19 · Beach near plane · act3Ilana captures Lapidus

Ilana and others take control of the plane survivors.

34:07–35:42threat · interrogation
20 · Temple entrance · act3Ben confesses to killing Alex

Ben admits to Locke he killed his daughter Alex.

35:42–36:50confession · secret_exposed
22 ▸ 38:45
22 · Temple interior · act3Ben hallucinates Alex

Ben hallucinates his daughter Alex blaming him.

38:45–41:29confession · secret_exposed
23 · Temple entrance · tagBen survives monster

Ben emerges from the Temple alive.

41:29–42:00comeuppance · secret_exposed
03

Same DNA

nearest episodes by gene profile

Episode facts

Wikipedia · Wikidata
Aired
April 8, 2009
Overall
#12
Writers
Brian K. Vaughan · & Elizabeth Sarnoff
Director
Stephen Williams
Pace
70 words/min · 118 questions

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 6 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
Dead is DeadDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.

In this episode