S05E12 · SCENE 18/21 · 32:41
Dead is Dead · Marina boat
Ben confronts Penny on boat
Ben holds Penny at gunpoint but hesitates.
32:41→34:07
in the episode · 1m 26s · S05E12
What happens
32:41–34:07Ben approaches Penny's boat. Desmond arrives and Ben shoots him. Ben holds Penny at gunpoint, blaming her father for Alex's death. Penny's son Charlie appears and Ben lowers his gun.
Key lines
from this scene32:42Hey! What are you doing here?
32:54Des?! Don't move! Not another word!
Scene DNA
weights 0–1argument
Beats
32:50Ben shoots Desmond
Scene in the episode
32:41–34:07Clips from this episode
fan uploads · YouTube · matched by frameIncludes this scene · LOST: Ben tries to shoot Penny [5x12-Dead is dead] · aadrienns
Lost - Ben shoots Cesar [5x12 - Dead Is Dead] · Artem Baranov
Lost 5x12 Dead is Dead - Smoke Monster Judges Ben · sledgeweb
LOST: Widmore's Exile [5x12-Dead is dead] · aadrienns
Who's in it

Desmond Hume67 episodes · drives 113 scenes
Charlie PaceDominic Monaghan72 episodes · drives 91 scenes
Merch on Amazon
sponsoredLinks may earn SceneClip a commission.
