S05E11 · SCENE 12/24 · 18:28
Whatever Happened, Happened · Infirmary and house

Hurley Questions Time Logic

Hurley challenges Miles' theory about time travel.

18:28→20:46
in the episode · 2m 18s · S05E11

What happens

18:28–20:46

Juliet says Ben is going into hypoxic shock. Hurley continues to question Miles about time travel. Hurley points out that if all this already happened, Ben should remember being shot. Miles admits he hadn't thought of that.

WhereInfirmary and house
DriverHurley
Positionact1 · complication
ThreadTime Travel Paradoxes

Key lines

from this scene
18:54

Yes! Then what am I gonna say next?

19:28

Our experiences in the past and the future occurred before these experiences right now.

More quotes on the Lost Wiki →

Scene DNA

weights 0–1
misunderstanding1.0
absurd1.0
tense1.0
argument

Beats

20:29Miles admits he hadn't thought of that.

Scene in the episode

18:28–20:46
A · Kate's Off-Island Journey
B · Saving Young Ben
C · Time Travel Paradoxes

Clips from this episode

fan uploads · YouTube · matched by frame
Lost - Jack refuses to fix young Ben in 1977 [5x11 - Whatever Happened, Happened] · Artem Baranov
LOST: Hurley and Miles about Time Travel · Ishidasouken
LOST 5.11 - "Whatever Happened, Happened" · lonarita

Who's in it

RL
Roger Linus7 episodes · drives 3 scenes

Collect it

eBay
More on eBay →
Links earn SceneClip a commission.

Merch on Amazon

sponsored
AMZN
Whatever Happened, Happened merchShirts, mugs, posters
Shop
AMZN
Juliet Burke merchFigures, shirts, gifts
Shop
AMZN
Roger Linus merchFigures, shirts, gifts
Shop
AMZN
Lost giftsGift ideas for fans
Shop
Links may earn SceneClip a commission.

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 6 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
Whatever Happened, HappenedDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.