S01E12 · EP 12
season 1 · 2005-01-05

Whatever the Case May Be

written by Damon Lindelof & · Jennifer Johnson · directed by Jack Bender · 21.59M viewers

Episode DNA

23 scenes · 4 threads
tense 13%violence 9%awkward 6%scheme 6%humiliation 4%angry 4%menacing 4%deal 4%sad 4%confession 4%

Story threads over runtime

click a block to open the scene
0:005:0010:0015:0020:00
A · Kate's Bank Heist
B · The Halliburton Case
C · Camp & Rousseau's Maps
D · Locke & Boone's Hatch
01

Every scene

23 scenes · our breakdown
1 · Jungle · act1Sawyer stalks Kate in jungle

Kate throws a rock at Sawyer after he startles her in the jungle.

01:31–02:35coincidence · avoidance
2 · Waterfall · act1Swimming at the waterfall

Kate and Sawyer swim at a waterfall and discover dead bodies underwater.

02:35–05:21coincidence
3 · Waterfall · act1Retrieving the Halliburton case

Kate asks Sawyer to retrieve a case from underwater, claiming it is hers.

05:21–07:30scheme · misunderstanding
4 · Beach · act1Jack and Sayid discuss moving

Jack and Sayid argue about moving inland and Rousseau's sanity.

07:30–09:04investigation
5 · Beach · act1Boone lies to Shannon

Boone lies to Shannon about searching for Claire with Locke.

09:04–10:17lie · humiliation
6 · Bank · act1Bank robbery begins

Masked robbers hold up the bank where Kate is applying for a loan.

10:17–11:59threat · violence
7 · Sawyer's tent · act1Kate tries to steal the case

Kate sneaks into Sawyer's tent at night to steal the Halliburton case.

11:59–13:11pursuit · violence
8 · Beach · act1Sayid asks Shannon for help

Sayid asks Shannon to translate Rousseau's French notations.

13:11–14:19deal
9 · Beach · act1Michael suggests opening the case

Michael and Hurley mock Sawyer and suggest using force to open the case.

14:19–15:03humiliation
10 · Jungle · act1Locke and Boone at the hatch

Locke and Boone continue trying to open the hatch with a smuggled axe.

15:03–15:36scheme
11 · Beach · act1Rose tries to help Charlie

Rose asks depressed Charlie to help move luggage.

15:36–16:42petty_grievance
12 · Jungle · act1Sawyer fails to open case

Sawyer hits the case on rocks but it still won't open.

16:42–17:42obsession
13 · Jungle · act1Sawyer propositions Kate

Sawyer offers Kate a deal to tell him what is inside the case.

17:42–18:39deal · negotiation
14 · Bank · act1Jason threatens Hutton

Jason threatens Hutton for the money cage key while Kate pretends to be a victim.

18:39–19:52scheme · impersonation
16 ▸ 20:21
16 · Beach · act1Shannon translates Rousseau's notes

Shannon begins translating Rousseau's French notations for Sayid.

20:21–21:37investigation
17 · Beach · act1Kate reveals case contains guns

Kate tells Jack the Halliburton case contains guns from a marshal.

21:37–23:45confession · deal
18 · Beach · act1Charlie blames himself

Rose comforts Charlie, who blames himself for Claire's kidnapping.

23:45–25:15confession
19 · Bank · act1Kate fakes being hit

Kate asks Jason to hit her to maintain the charade for Hutton.

25:15–26:32scheme · violence
20 · Bank vault · act1Kate shoots Jason and opens box

Kate shoots Jason and his accomplices, then opens deposit box 815.

26:32–28:05betrayal · violence
21 · Beach · act1Shannon and Sayid argue over translation

Shannon and Sayid argue about the nonsensical French translations.

28:05–29:31misunderstanding · humiliation
22 · Beach · act1Jack threatens Sawyer for the case

Jack threatens to withhold Sawyer's antibiotics to get the Halliburton case.

29:31–31:39threat · negotiation
23 · Bank vault · act1Kate double-crosses Jason

Kate shoots Jason and his accomplices, then reveals her true goal to Hutton.

31:39–34:25betrayal · violence
24 ▸ 34:25
24 · Beach · act1Kate reveals envelope contents

Kate opens the envelope and reveals it belonged to the man she killed.

34:25–39:36confession · secret_exposed
03

Same DNA

nearest episodes by gene profile

Episode facts

Wikipedia · Wikidata
Aired
2005-01-05
Overall
#12
Writers
Damon Lindelof & · Jennifer Johnson
Director
Jack Bender
Viewers
21.59M (US)
Pace
73 words/min · 122 questions

Where to watch

sponsored
TV
Stream all 6 seasonsWhere it's streaming now · JustWatch
Find
BD
The Complete SeriesBlu-ray / DVD box set
Shop
EP
Whatever the Case May BeDigital purchase
Buy
Links may earn SceneClip a commission. Illustrative availability.