S01E12 · SCENE 18/23 · 23:45
Whatever the Case May Be · Beach
Charlie blames himself
Rose comforts Charlie, who blames himself for Claire's kidnapping.
23:45→25:15
in the episode · 1m 30s · S01E12
What happens
23:45–25:15Rose talks to Charlie, who is depressed and blames himself for Claire's kidnapping. Rose tells him it is not his fault and that he needs to ask for help.
Key lines
from this scene24:39You know what I think, Charlie?
24:48Who's gonna help me?
Scene DNA
weights 0–1Beats
24:25Rose says it's not Charlie's fault
Scene in the episode
23:45–25:15Clips from this episode
fan uploads · YouTube · matched by frameLOST Sayid gets Shannon to translate Danielle's maps Season 1 Episode 12 · itsSydneY_oK
Lost - Charlie and Rose pray - 1x12 Whatever the Case May Be · Luke Koran
Who's in it

Rose Nadler18 episodes · drives 10 scenes
Charlie PaceDominic Monaghan72 episodes · drives 91 scenes
Merch on Amazon
sponsoredLinks may earn SceneClip a commission.
